Banished by Bargain:
third Country deportation watch
Monitoring the human cost of the U.S. government’s forced third country transfer agreements
agreements signed with at least 35 countries
+28,800 people sent to 31 countries
+$95 million in U.S. government funding directly to other governments
The Trump administration has created an opaque web of formal bilateral agreements and behind-the-scenes deals that send asylum seekers, refugees, and other immigrants—with almost no warning and little chance to raise fears of persecution or torture—to countries with which they have no ties and where many are subject to grave human rights abuses including arbitrary detention or return to danger in the very countries they once fled.
The policy is one of the Trump administration’s most coercive tools to spread fear and punish people who have already been granted—or are seeking—legal protections in the United States. The agreements treat immigrants and refugees as bargaining chips, reflecting the Trump administration’s transactional and corrupt approach to foreign policy.
This tracker from Refugees International and Human Rights First shines a light on these U.S. third country transfer agreements, the political and financial motives behind them, and the harms they have caused—as well as relevant lawsuits and other efforts to challenge them.
For ICE flight tracking, visit ICE Flight Monitor on X and Bluesky
EXPLORE AGREEMENTS BY Region and Country
Africa
Burundi | Cameroon | Cabo Verde | Central African Republic
Democratic Republic of the Congo | Equatorial Guinea | Eswatini
Ghana | Guinea Bissau | Liberia | Libya | Rwanda
Sierra Leone | South Sudan | Uganda
Americas
Antigua and Barbuda | Bahamas | Belize | Costa Rica
Dominica | Dominican Republic | Ecuador | El Salvador
Grenada | Guatemala | Guyana | Honduras | Jamaica | Mexico
Panama | Paraguay | St. Kitts and Nevis | St. Lucia
Explore The Map
Tracking the Human Cost
Forced third country transfers have separated parents from children, spouses from one another, and cut people off from their communities in the United States. In many cases, they have resulted in enforced disappearances, arbitrary detention, and unlawful refoulement (where people are sent to persecution in the country they fled, either directly or via third country). Many people transferred to third countries are left in limbo and precarity: lacking legal status, identity documents, or any way to provide for their most basic needs. The toll on individuals and family members is profound: mental anguish, uncertainty, and no safe path to reunification.
Beyond those already forcibly sent to third countries, tens of thousands of asylum seekers, refugees, and immigrants in the United States have had their court proceedings thrown out without a hearing on their asylum claim or been arrested and subjected to prolonged detention because the U.S. government claims it intends to transfer them to third countries.
-
Our methodology uses transparency requests, on-the-ground sources, and public reporting to determine the number of removed third-country nationals.
This tracker currently does not include deportations that involve a layover in a third country before onward transport to their country of origin, and where the third country has not agreed to process and accept them—for example, Iranians removed to Tehran via Qatar and Kuwait, Venezuelans removed to Caracas via Honduras, Russians removed to Moscow via Egypt, Ukrainians removed to Ukraine via Poland, and Somalis to Somalia via Kenya. We are investigating reports of an arrangement with Pakistan concerning the deportation of Afghans and Iranians, and will update the site as details are confirmed.
The texts of agreements between the United States and other countries regarding the deportation of third country nationals have mostly been posted, long after they have been negotiated and signed, on a U.S. State Department website or in the U.S. federal register. The UC Berkeley Human Rights Center has collected these documents into a user-friendly reading room. On each of its country pages, Third Country Deportation Watch links to the documents there. The texts of the agreements with Bahamas, Guinea Bissau, Jamaica, Mexico, Moldova, Saint Lucia, and Uzbekistan remain undisclosed.
Though documents have not been made public about them, the arrangement between Mexico and the United States to receive third country nationals (about 20,700 from January 2025 through September 2026) and arrangements between the United States and several Latin American countries to receive Mexican nationals (over 5,500 from January 2025 through October 2026) are included on Third Country Deportation Watch.
*Third Country Deportation Watch does not track ad hoc forced third country transfers carried out on commercial flights. -
Arrangements to incarcerate forcibly transferred people in prisons in El Salvador, Eswatini, and South Sudan until eventual onward transfer.
Arrangements for temporary transfer before onward return to home country with Cameroon, Central African Republic, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Equatorial Guinea, Ghana, Panama, and Sierra Leone. In most instances, this has also included arbitrary detention.
“Asylum Cooperative Agreements” (ACA) or attempts at “safe third country agreements” (STCA) with Belize, Cabo Verde, Ecuador, Guatemala, Honduras, Liberia, Paraguay, and Uganda, where people transferred purportedly may pursue an asylum claim.
Other types of arrangements that may include detention, onward transfer, and/or remaining in the third country, such as with Mexico and Rwanda, and a new 2026 agreement with Costa Rica (following a separate 2025 agreement).
In some cases, there are multiple arrangements with the same third country. For instance, many of the countries that originally signed an Asylum Cooperative Agreement subsequently agreed to receive forcibly transferred third country nationals from the United States outside the parameters of the ACA or pursuant to another agreement, including Guatemala, Honduras, Paraguay, Ecuador, and Liberia.
*Given the lack of sufficient tracked transfers and treatment upon arrival, the arrangements with the following countries cannot yet be categorized: Antigua and Barbuda, Bahamas, Burundi, Dominica, Grenada, Guyana, Kosovo, Moldova, Palau, St. Lucia, St. Kitts and Nevis, and Uzbekistan.
-
As of early September 2026, the Trump administration has used these deals to send over 25,000 third country nationals to at least 31 countries (Belize, Burundi, Cameroon, Central African Republic, Costa Rica, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Dominica, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, El Salvador, Equatorial Guinea, Eswatini, Ghana, Guatemala, Guyana, Honduras, Jamaica, Kosovo, Liberia, Mexico, Moldova, Palau, Panama, Paraguay, Rwanda, Sierra Leone, St. Kitts and Nevis, St. Lucia, South Sudan, Uganda and Uzbekistan). It also attempted to send people to Libya in violation of a court order.
Most third countries have received only a few dozen people or fewer, on flights without a regular cadence. The vast majority of removals of third country nationals have been to Mexico, where over 20,000 people have been sent since January 20, 2025 (including thousands of people that the Trump administration has not acknowledged in its accounting to a federal court). A March 2026 agreement with Costa Rica provides for regular transfers of 25 people per week. Since June 2026, one flight a month has transferred third country nationals from the United States to the Central African Republic, except for in September, when a U.S. federal court ruled that such deportations were unlawful. Third country deportations to CAR resumed in October after the Supreme Court issued an emergency stay of the federal court’s ruling.
The administration has also entered into agreements with at least five other countries, including Antigua and Barbuda, Bahamas, Cabo Verde, Grenada, and Guinea Bissau, where transfers have not yet occurred as far as is publicly known. Country pages for these agreements (with the exception of a Guinea Bissau page in progress) are included on this site. We will update this site with new country pages if additional agreements are signed.
The U.S. and Uruguay have also been negotiating an agreement which, like other agreements, has sparked opposition from politicians and civil society. Some countries, such as Burkina Faso, Nigeria, Chad, Sudan, and Zimbabwe, have declined to sign agreements with the United States.
A separate project led by Human Rights First, ICE Flight Monitor, tracks U.S. removal flights, including those to third countries, to bring transparency to government operations that are often hidden from public view. ICE Flight Monitor tracks third country transfer flights in real time via Bluesky and X, and its monthly reports include a comprehensive list of all third country transfer flights with plane and flight information. -
The Trump administration has used these deals to banish to third countries men, women, children, and families, including pregnant people, individuals with medical or psychological vulnerabilities, and those granted legal protections by the United States. People who have been forcibly transferred from the United States under these arrangements have come from a wide range of countries across the globe. This tracker’s country pages specify the nationalities and number of people sent to each third country.
The administration has forcibly transferred asylum seekers and other migrants at various stages of their immigration case, including:people arriving in the United States to seek asylum who are expelled without consideration of their claim.
people in the midst of their immigration court case who have not received a full hearing on their asylum claim or a decision from a judge.
people to whom U.S. immigration judges have granted protection, known as withholding of removal and Convention Against Torture (CAT) protection, due to likely torture or persecution in their home countries. This includes many people who would have been granted asylum but were not because of an unlawful regulation that has been struck down by a federal court.
people with final orders of removal for whom removal to the third country was never raised by the government.
-
When people arrive in third countries, many face arbitrary detention, insecurity and poor conditions, lack of access to protection or lawful status, and deportation to their countries of origin through force or coercion. The administration has sent people to some of the most dangerous countries in the world, such as the Central African Republic and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, where armed groups or security forces carry out massacres, abductions, sexual violence, and other human rights abuses. In many of the third countries where the Trump administration has forcibly deported people, LGBTQ+ individuals face a range of harms including criminalization, arbitrary detention, torture, physical assaults, sexual violence, and/or abuses by government agents. Nonetheless, the administration has deported at least 45 LGBTQ+ people granted withholding and CAT protections, and likely many others, to these countries.
People forcibly transferred to third countries have often been detained upon arrival, including at a maximum-security prison, military camp, a government facility under armed guard, or hotels where they are not allowed to leave or have restricted movement. In some cases, people have been detained incommunicado. While detained, people have fallen ill with malaria and other sicknesses, experienced denial of medical care, and reported unsanitary and crowded conditions and lack of access to hygiene products. Some have also been tortured for sharing information about their mistreatment with the media and journalists attempting to speak with transferred individuals have been detained.
In many cases, authorities in the third country forcibly deport people to their countries of origin, even if they have been granted protections in the United States that prohibit their return to their countries of origin due to risk of persecution or torture. This practice constitutes chain refoulement and violates U.S. law and the fundamental principle of non-refoulement. Other refugees and torture survivors face intense pressure to return to their countries of origin while trapped in harsh conditions, unable to unite with family, work legally, and vulnerable to exploitation and abuse, or arbitrarily detained in a country where they do not feel safe and with no legal pathways, leading to returns that are characterized as “voluntary” but may also amount to chain refoulement. -
The administration’s policy punishes immigrants and asylum seekers and deprives them of their rights under U.S. law. Third country deportations are a part of the administration’s racist promotion of “re-migration.”
Under this policy, the U.S. government is disappearing people, including people who have lived in the United States for decades, to unknown locations before family members and lawyers can help them, sending them to face arbitrary detention, torture, chain refoulement, and other harms. The mistreatment in the third country is inflicted not for any crime committed there or in the United States, but because they were immigrants in the United States subjected to a forced transfer arrangement.
In addition to punishing immigrants subjected to the agreements, the administration wields the threat of forced transfers to terrify immigrant communities and force people to leave the United States, including by publicly warning: “If you do not leave, we will hunt you down, arrest you, and you could end up in this El Salvadorian prison.” A U.S. official stated to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee that “the point is that the Administration can threaten people that they will literally be dropped in the middle of nowhere. The point is to scare people.” U.S. immigration officials also directly threaten detained immigrants with transfer to a third country in order to coerce them to relinquish their rights and abandon their immigration cases. In some cases, the U.S. government seems motivated to not only punish immigrants and terrify others, but perhaps also to pressure other governments into accepting the return of their own nationals.
The Trump administration is using third country deportation agreements to undermine refugee protection globally and undermine adherence of governments around the world to the obligation of non-refoulement (not to return people to persecution) in the UN Convention on the Status of Refugees and the Convention Against Torture. The administration has increasingly deported to third countries people in the United States determined by U.S. immigration judges to be refugees or in need of protection from torture and granted withholding or deferral of removal to their countries of origin. Many are then refouled onward to the countries from which they were granted protection from persecution and torture. Agreements with third countries often include boilerplate language about adherence to these international treaties, but are routinely violated. The agreements may continue to push other countries to violate their human rights commitments, further undermining the rule of law globally.
The administration is also using Asylum Cooperative Agreements (ACAs) as a pretext to “pretermit” thousands of pending asylum cases in immigration court, refusing to consider the applicants’ asylum claims and instead issuing removal orders to third countries. This tactic is being used to automatically deny people’s asylum cases irrespective of their claim and send some to third countries, while the vast majority of asylum seekers with pretermitted cases—tens of thousands of people—are left in limbo with a removal order and facing loss of their work permit, many subject to prolonged detention or at risk of being detained, without ever having had an opportunity to present their case. Pretermissions are discussed in more detail below.As noted above, in 2026, the United States signed new, superseding third country deportation agreements with many of the same countries with which it initially signed ACAs, further indicating that the ACAs were simply a pretext to throw asylum cases out of immigration court.
-
Through forced third country transfer agreements, the Trump administration has warped U.S. international relations in service of its deportation agenda. In many cases, the reasons countries have agreed to receive third country nationals remain murky, often bound up in pressure and incentives from the Trump administration, as well as broader bilateral geopolitical and financial interests.At the time that many of these agreements were signed and implemented, the Trump administration imposed or threatened third countries with visa bans, deportation of their own nationals, tariffs, and other trade barriers, as detailed in the country sections. The Trump administration also has provided funding to some of the third countries, including for migration and border enforcement, defense, and condoned corruption, repression, and violations of human rights by governments in third countries.
Third Country Deportation Watch has tracked that the U.S. government has paid at least $95 million directly to third country governments in connection with the agreements (which does not include the costs of flights). This includes $4 million to the government of Burundi, $7 million to the Dominican Republic, $4.76 million to the government of El Salvador, $7.5 million to the government of Equatorial Guinea, $5.1 million to the government of Eswatini, $15.2 million to the government of Guatemala, $15 million to the government of Honduras, $5 million to the government of Liberia, $7.5 million to the government of Palau, $14 million to the government of Panama, $7.5 million to the government of Rwanda, $1.5 million to Sierra Leone, $250,000 to the government of Moldova, $200,000 to the government of St Kitts and Nevis, and $310,000 to the government of Dominica.
Other U.S. incentives are more indirect. Some deals seem to be tied to U.S. investment in mining or other sectors or support for public health or other aid, albeit more restricted and limited than the United States provided in the past given massive U.S. cuts in humanitarian aid since January 2025. The administration has also diverted State Department funding formerly devoted to support and services for refugees abroad to these deportation agreements. Indeed, the administration has made funding available to the UN Refugee Agency and the International Organization for Migration in countries with existing agreements so that they can work with immigrants, refugees, and asylum seekers forcefully transferred there by the United States. For IOM, this includes $8 million in Burundi, $85 million CAR, and $22.6 million in Costa Rica. For UNHCR, this includes $30 million in Cameroon, $50 million for the DRC, and $9 million in Uganda. -
The administration has used a range of unlawful tactics to attempt to justify these transfers, some in unprecedented ways. In response to litigation filed by legal services organizations and immigrants, federal courts have repeatedly held the administration’s forced transfers to be unlawful. The administration has appealed some of these decisions and requested stays pending appeal. As a result, U.S. courts have in some cases temporarily paused the rulings, paving the way for the government to continue to forcibly transfer people to harm in third countries while litigation is ongoing. Even where court orders remain in effect, the Trump administration has carried out some forced transfers in direct violation of court orders that were in full force at the time.
The Trump administration has attempted to invoke various provisions in U.S. law to carry out forced transfers. It has implemented a systematic policy to deport to third countries people with final orders of removal and is increasingly using this policy to target people granted withholding of removal or protection under the Convention Against Torture. These include dozens of people denied asylum and granted withholding of removal solely due to a regulation that had been ruled unlawful by a federal court at the time that the U.S. government forcibly transferred them to third countries. These also include people granted protections by judges and released from detention after prevailing on a habeas claim, only to be re-arrested by ICE and removed to a third country. The administration’s policy, which denies people notice or an opportunity to raise a fear claim with respect to the third country, purportedly relies on a U.S. law provision governing countries to which people with final orders of removal may be removed. A federal district court and court of appeals have both struck down the policy as unlawful. The government, however, has sought and obtained stays of these decisions while the Supreme Court considers the case, and has continued to escalate its unlawful third-country removals in the meantime.
The administration has also invoked a U.S. law provision on safe third country agreements to enter into at least eight Asylum Cooperative Agreements (ACAs), under which the U.S. government forcibly sends people to third countries without a chance to have their asylum case considered in the United States. These ACAs do not meet the congressionally-mandated requirements for such agreements—namely that the asylum seeker is safe in the third country and has access to full and fair asylum procedures. Ongoing litigation challenges the regulation and associated agency guidance that provide the framework for these ACA removals, as well as the designation of the ACA countries as having full and fair asylum systems.
The administration has unlawfully invoked Constitutional authority to respond to an “invasion” to shut down access to asylum at the border and forcibly send people seeking asylum to Costa Rica and Panama. This policy also relied on a U.S. law provision on “suspension of entry” that was enacted long before codification of the Refugee Convention and its Protocol. A federal district court and court of appeals have both struck down the asylum shutdown policy as unlawful, but the court of appeal’s ruling has not yet taken effect and the government is appealing the ruling to the Supreme Court. The administration has also invoked a centuries-old wartime law (the Alien Enemies Act, 50 U.S.C. §§ 21-24) to send Venezuelans to a maximum-security prison in El Salvador. A federal court ordered the United States to facilitate the return of people expelled to El Salvador under the Alien Enemies Act (which the government has appealed) and an appeals court is considering whether Trump administration officials can be held accountable for violating a federal judge’s order in carrying out the expulsions.
In addition to the litigation discussed above, attorneys have also had some success in individual cases, such as by opposing the government’s efforts to pretermit asylum cases under ACAs and successfully challenging forced third country transfers through habeas corpus petitions. In some cases, federal courts have ordered the U.S. government to facilitate the return to the United States of people deported to third countries. Additional guidance for attorneys is included in the resources page of this site.
Lawyers and members of civil society in third countries have brought challenges in their courts and international and regional bodies regarding their governments’ treatment—including detention, refoulement, and other human rights violations—of those transferred by the United States to their counties. Politicians in third countries have demanded more transparency regarding the agreements and other governments have at times refused to sign third country agreements and denied requests for transfers from the Trump administration.
Members of the U.S. Congress and international bodies have condemned the unlawfulness of forced transfers and the lack of transparency around the agreements. -
The Trump administration has carried out a systematic effort to detain and deport people granted refugee and torture protection in the United States. U.S. immigration judges have granted these individuals withholding of removal or Convention Against Torture protection, which prohibits their deportation to their countries of origin because they are more likely than not to face persecution or torture there. Because these protection grants are accompanied by a removal order, the Trump administration is detaining and forcibly sending people to third countries, including people who have lived in the United States for years or decades. Under Trump administration policy that has been ruled unlawful by multiple federal courts, the government often provides little to no notice prior to the forced transfer and denies many refugees and torture survivors an opportunity to present a fear claim for the third country. This systematic effort is unprecedented: previously, people with these court-ordered protection grants were largely able to live the rest of their lives in the United States after proving their case to an immigration judge.
As of the beginning of October 2026, Trump administration has sent at least 310 individuals granted refugee or torture protection to Burundi, Cameroon, Central African Republic, Democratic Republic of Congo, Equatorial Guinea, Eswatini, Ghana, Liberia, Mexico, Moldova, Rwanda, Sierra Leone, St. Lucia, St. Kitts and Nevis, and Uzbekistan. At least 45 people are LGBTQ. At least 114 people were then returned to their countries of origin, including people who fled anti-LGBTQ harms, female genital mutilation, forced marriage, religious persecution, and hereditary slavery—in many cases amounting to unlawful chain refoulement and violating purported diplomatic assurances provided by third countries. To carry out this large-scale deportation effort, the administration is systematically detaining people granted withholding and CAT protection for prolonged periods in ICE detention, where they endure life-threatening and abusive conditions and the psychological terror of not knowing when or where in the world they will be sent. -
The Trump administration has wielded generic diplomatic assurances provided by third countries to carry out forced removals without any semblance of due process.
With respect to the forced transfers of people with final removal orders, including those granted withholding of removal or CAT protection, the U.S. government has taken the position that it is not required to provide a person any notice or an opportunity to present a fear claim before deporting them to a country that was never raised during immigration proceedings, so long as the country has given blanket “diplomatic assurances” that people sent there will not be persecuted or tortured and the Department of State deems those assurances to be credible. In the absence of “credible” diplomatic assurances, the government’s policy is to generally provide notice as little as 24 hours—or six hours in exigent circumstances—before deporting someone to a third country, and to refer a person for a fear interview only if they affirmatively express fear of removal to the country.
This policy, which denies people individualized assessments of their claims and delivers them to countries where they may face harm or be sent onward to persecution or torture, has been struck down by multiple federal courts, but the government continues to implement it while its appeal to the Supreme Court is pending. In a decision affirming a district court ruling striking down the policy, the First Circuit Court of Appeals noted: “It is difficult to see how [the policy] conforms to the detailed statutory and regulatory regime that [never]...contemplates the substitution of blanket diplomatic assurances for the detailed and individualized procedures governing such a claim…[W]e have some difficulty seeing how a receiving country can credibly provide blanket assurances that all removed noncitizens will not be persecuted or tortured there unless it intends to provide them with some sort of affirmative protection against rogue agents and non-state actors, who can be persecutors...and torturers.”
Diplomatic assurances, in many cases, are worth little to nothing. Many agreements with third countries include generic language that third country nationals will not face persecution or torture in the receiving country and will not be sent onward to a country where they face persecution and torture. This language is replicated verbatim across multiple agreements and in other instances includes minor variations in language. It is impossible for any state to provide reliable assurances as to the treatment—whether by its own agents or non-state actors—of an entire class of people whose individual circumstances, identities, and nationalities it does not yet know. Diplomatic assurances are routinely violated, including in numerous cases where third countries have sent third country nationals to to their countries of origin, even though U.S. judges found they face persecution or torture there, and in several cases have tortured third country nationals. A February 2026 Senate Foreign Relations Committee report found that the United States is not tracking compliance or enforcing agreement terms, even where third countries appear to violate their commitments, and in at least one instance instructed U.S. officials to not follow up on how people forcibly sent to a third country were treated. -
Since the second half of 2025, attorneys for ICE have filed tens of thousands of motions in immigration court to pretermit asylum applications pursuant to Asylum Cooperative Agreements with one or multiple third countries. It is extremely difficult for an asylum seeker to contest the motion and make a case against removal to those countries, particularly if unrepresented. When a judge grants the motion, they refuse to consider an applicant’s asylum claim and instead issue a removal order to a third country.
On March 13, 2026, DHS directed ICE attorneys to halt filing new motions to pretermit asylum claims per the ACAs—but not to withdraw motions that were already pending. ICE attorneys continue to argue in support of pretermission motions and judges continue to pretermit cases, thus refusing to consider them on the merits, and to order asylum seekers removed to ACA countries. Third Country Deportation Watch has also received reports that ICE attorneys have resumed filing ACA-based pretermission motions in some cases.
The organization Mobile Pathways used publicly available Executive Office of Immigration Review data to track 32,848 pretermissions of individual asylum cases with an Asylum Cooperative Agreement country (Belize, Ecuador, Guatemala, Honduras, or Uganda) listed as the first country of removal for non-nationals of those countries through September 2026. There have been 33 for Belize, 19,920 for Ecuador, 1,876 for Guatemala, 8,174 for Honduras, and 2,845 for Uganda.
As of October 2026, Third Country Deportation Watch estimates that up to 300 third country nationals have been actually removed through the Asylum Cooperative Agreements: over 121 to Ecuador, 130 to Honduras, 8 to Uganda, and 9 to Belize; it is unclear if or how many transfers of third country nationals to Guatemala have been carried out pursuant to the ACA. Given the large discrepancy between ACA-based pretermissions and actual deportations pursuant to the ACAs, pretermissions seem aimed to throw out from immigration court large numbers of asylum cases without consideration of the persecution or torture people fear, coerce people in need of protection to abandon their claims rather than face an order of removal to a third country, deter people from seeking protection in the United States, and put vulnerable people at risk of harm in U.S. detention or through removal to a third country.
What are Forced third country transfers?
We are using this term to describe the deportation or expulsion of individuals from the United States to third countries where they are not citizens and to which they are forcibly sent, often exposing them to harm or the risk of chain refoulement. These transfers occur through various bilateral agreements and arrangements between the United States and other governments.
What are Enforced Disappearances?
The arrest, detention, abduction, or other deprivation of a person’s liberty by state agents—or by others with the state’s approval, support, or acquiescence—followed by a refusal to acknowledge the detention or by hiding the person’s fate or whereabouts. This places the person outside the protection of the law.
What is arbitrary detention?
Arbitrary detention is the deprivation of liberty that lacks a legal basis, such as conviction for a crime, or, even when tethered to a cause and authorized by law, is unreasonable or disproportionate and carried out without due process. Detention is considered arbitrary when individuals are detained without relation to their own actions, not promptly informed of the reasons for their detention, are denied access to judicial review or the ability to challenge its lawfulness, are held for prolonged or indefinite periods, or are detained in a discriminatory manner. Even where domestic law permits detention, it may still be arbitrary if it is unnecessary or lacks justification or adequate procedural safeguards.

